Launch offer: 30% off everything until November 30 with code LAUNCH30, applied automatically at checkout.
Free guide

How to Compare Job Offers: A Weighted Scoring Method

To compare job offers fairly, first work out the total yearly value of each offer, not just the salary. Then list the factors that matter to you, give each a weight, score each offer on each factor and multiply. The weighted totals show which offer fits your priorities best, and the exercise often reveals what you really care about.

The template for thisHome and Life Planning Bundle $11.90 · 30% off

Step by step

  1. Get each offer in writing with salary, bonus, benefits, hours, location and start date.
  2. Calculate total compensation for each one.
  3. List the factors that matter to you, usually five to eight.
  4. Give each factor a weight so that the weights add up to 100.
  5. Score each offer on each factor from 1 to 10.
  6. Multiply each score by its weight, add them up and divide by 100.
  7. Sense-check the result against your gut reaction.

1. Compare total compensation

Salary is only one part of an offer. Add up everything with a money value.

Offer AOffer B
Base salary82,00076,000
Expected yearly bonus4,0006,000
Employer retirement contribution3,280 (4% of salary)4,560 (6% of salary)
Total89,28086,560

A 6,000 salary gap shrinks to 2,720 once the bonus and retirement contribution are included. Other items to value where you can:

  • Health, dental and other insurance paid by the employer.
  • Paid holiday. Extra days off have real value.
  • Shares or equity. These are uncertain, so value them cautiously.
  • Commuting cost and time, or savings from working at home.
  • Training budgets, equipment, meals, childcare support.
  • One-off items such as a signing bonus or relocation help, which only count once.

Bonuses are rarely guaranteed, so ask how often the full amount has actually been paid.

2. Choose your factors

Common factors include:

  • Pay and benefits
  • Growth and learning
  • Work-life balance and flexibility
  • Commute or remote working
  • The manager and team
  • Job security and company stability
  • The work itself
  • Company culture and values

Pick the ones that genuinely matter to you. A list that tries to include everything stops being useful.

3. Weight and score

Give each factor a weight out of 100 according to its importance, then score each offer from 1 (poor) to 10 (excellent).

FactorWeightOffer A scoreOffer B score
Pay and benefits3097
Growth and learning2568
Work-life balance2058
Commute1049
Other benefits1587
Weighted score1006.807.65

The calculation for Offer A is (30 x 9 + 25 x 6 + 20 x 5 + 10 x 4 + 15 x 8) / 100 = 680 / 100 = 6.80. For Offer B it is (30 x 7 + 25 x 8 + 20 x 8 + 10 x 9 + 15 x 7) / 100 = 765 / 100 = 7.65.

Offer A pays more, but Offer B scores higher overall because it does better on growth, balance and commute, which together carry 55 of the 100 points.

4. Test the result

The score is a tool for thinking, not a verdict. Check it three ways.

  • Change the weights. If pay were 50 instead of 30, would the answer flip? If small changes swap the winner, the offers are genuinely close.
  • Notice your reaction. If you are disappointed by the winner, a factor you care about is missing or under-weighted. Add it and score again.
  • Look for deal-breakers. A weighted average can hide a single unacceptable item, such as a commute you cannot sustain. Treat those as pass or fail before scoring.

Questions to ask before deciding

  • What does a typical week look like, and what are the real working hours?
  • How is performance measured, and when are pay reviews?
  • What happened to the last person in this role?
  • How many days are expected in the office?
  • When do benefits and retirement contributions start?
  • What notice period and probation period apply?

Negotiating and deadlines

It is normal to ask for a few days to consider an offer, and to ask whether there is flexibility on pay, start date or working pattern. Be polite, specific and honest. If you are waiting on a second employer, you can tell them you have an offer with a deadline and ask about their timeline. Do not invent offers you do not have.

Take-home pay depends on tax and deductions where you live, so compare offers after tax if they are in different places. Read any contract carefully, and get professional advice on anything you do not understand, such as restrictive clauses or equity terms. This guide is general information, not financial, tax or legal advice.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing salary alone.
  • Counting an uncertain bonus or equity at full value.
  • Ignoring the commute. An hour each way is about ten hours a week.
  • Scoring to justify a decision already made. Set the weights before you score.
  • Overlooking the manager. The person you report to shapes the job more than most benefits do.
  • Deciding under pressure without getting the full offer in writing.

Score your offers side by side

The Content Crib Job Search Tracker includes an offer comparison with a weighted score, alongside applications with stages and automatic follow-up dates, interviews, contacts, weekly application goals and a funnel dashboard. It works in Excel, Google Sheets and Apple Numbers.

Home and Life Planning Bundle preview

Skip the blank page

The Home and Life Planning Bundle includes the Job Search Tracker, laid out and ready to use. $11.90, instant download.

Get the Home and Life Planning Bundle

Related guides